Rothenberg Ventures management team with Mike Nothenberg (fifth from left) (Click Image To Enlarge)
Rothenberg Ventures, the four-year-old, San Francisco-based seed-stage venture firm, may be on the brink of implosion, say several sources close to the firm.
We reported yesterday that several high-level employees had parted ways with Rothenberg, including:
- Tom Leep, Director of Finance (father of Tommy Lepp)
- Tommy Leep, Partner, Head of San Francisco Office (left July 2016)
- Chief Revenue Officer (left August 17, 2016)
- Chief Financial Officer (left in June 2016)
- James Taylor, General Manager (left August 2016)
- Fran Hauser, Partner (left July 2016; Hauser was a former president of digital at Time Inc. Hauser was brought in with some fanfare as a venture partner in May 2014. Yesterday, she updated her LinkedIn profile to reflect that she left Rothenberg in July.
Messages to Rothenberg have not been returned. According to one source, Rothenberg Ventures founder Mike Rothenberg has told those remaining that “very few people will be left.” In what appears to be a related development, the firm’s site has also been down since last night.
Why the mass exodus? According to one source, Rothenberg Ventures is under investigation by the SEC after a lower-level employee alerted the agency to what this person reported as wire fraud and breach of fiduciary duty. This same source says the employee was subsequently fired and is now suing the firm for retaliation.
All SEC investigations are conducted privately. An investigation does not mean that the agency will file a case in federal court or bring an administrative action.
Either way, a much thornier issue for Rothenberg Ventures, say numerous former employees, is founder Rothenberg himself, who has sometimes seemed to live more like a billionaire than the manager of a modest venture fund — spending lavishly to attract moneyed individuals as investors and, over time, growing increasingly focused on becoming as famous as some of them.
Making a millionaire
It all began as a minor if inspirational story, proof that the American Dream can still come true.
Rothenberg, an Austin native who says he comes from humble means — “no one in my family has any money,” he once told us — was smart enough to nab an undergraduate, then graduate degree, from Stanford, then bootstrap a real estate fund with his brother before moving on to Harvard to secure an MBA.
Soon afterward, inspired by business leaders he had met while at Stanford, Rothenberg planted himself in San Francisco and got down to the business of trying to shake up the stodgy venture industry. Step one involved raising a $5 million fund from “friends, family, and former roommates,” as reported in a Bloomberg story about Rothenberg last year.
His timing was ideal as these things go. In 2012, the market was in the middle of a three-year upswing, following the financial crisis of late 2008. A number of newer faces was also beginning to gain prominence in the venture industry, along with the trust of so-called limited partners — the individuals and institutions that fund venture firms.
Rothenberg is also a natural salesperson, and as such, quickly evolved his pitch for Rothenberg from yet another seed-stage fund to a thought-leading outfit willing to make big bets on virtual reality before most people in Silicon Valley saw it as a major opportunity.
Indeed, by late 2014, Rothenberg Ventures — whose more garden-variety bets include the clothing company Chubbies and the floral delivery startup BloomThat — announced it was launching a virtual reality startup accelerator, River, and that it planned to provide $100,000 in seed funding to virtual reality companies expressly. Among its bets was Fove, which makes an eye-tracking head-mounted display and went on to raise an $11 million Series A round earlier this year.
Rothenberg Ventures founder Mike Rothenberg durng promotion of RIVER, a virtual reality accelerator (Click Image To Enlarge)
But employees say that as the firm grew, so too did Rothenberg’s spending, and not merely on their paychecks.
Among the expensive ways that Rothenberg found to market the firm to prospective limited partners, he hired race-car driver Collete Davis and spent hundreds of thousands of dollars more to maintain and transport her race car to events. Another $200,000 reportedly went toward a suite at the Super Bowl that was meant to woo investors.
Rothenberg Ventures — which counts many people in tech and finance as backers, including Jeff Seibert, a former head of product at Twitter, and Michael Cronin, founder of the private equity firm Weston Presidio — also inserted itself increasingly into celebrity circles, say employees, including buying tickets to the Golden Globes, co-sponsoring actor Chase Crawford’s 30th birthday party in West Hollywood, and spending unsparingly to executive produce a video for Coldplay.
Says one source, “Mike wants to be famous.”
They say he began to live as if he were, too, with many other examples of seemingly out-of-control spending. Among them, says one source, Rothenberg had hired up to three executive assistants at one point. He also employed a personal assistant for himself and a private driver. Further, employees say he refused to fly coach and instead maintained a $2,000-per-month membership with the young, subscription-only airline service Surf Air.
They also say Rothenberg began to spend an inordinate amount of time managing his reputation, as questions began to surface around how he afforded it all. When Bloomberg last year questioned the firm’s ability to finance itself, Rothenberg sent two employees to SFO, purchasing them airline tickets so they could head to airport newsstands and buy copies of the issue in hopes that it wouldn’t be as widely read.
All the while, Rothenberg was hiring, employing up to 60 people across Rothenberg Ventures at one point. For a firm that manages hundreds of millions of dollars, that wouldn’t be a startling amount of overhead. But Rothenberg Ventures has raised $47 million across four funds dating back to 2013, according to SEC filings. Given that firms typically collect 2 percent of what they raise in management fees, that would leave just $940,000 for Rothenberg’s entire operation. In fact, most funds of a similar size are run by two or three people.
What happens now is anyone’s guess, including whether Rothenberg will be forced to sell any stakes in the company’s 100-plus portfolio companies to a secondaries specialist. When we asked a founder of a top secondaries shop for more information today, the executive declined to provide any information, saying only that Rothenberg Ventures “has been super nice to me.”
Certainly, while employees paint a picture of an overly ambitious founder who paid too little attention to his firm’s finances, many outsiders like Rothenberg and benefited richly from Rothenberg Ventures’ generosity.
Among its most popular events is an annual Founders Field Day at AT&T Park, where the San Francisco Giants play. In April of last year, the outlet Recode likened it to a scene lifted from “Silicon Valley” after the HBO show opened its second season, two weeks earlier, with a scene at the baseball park.
Employees say Rothenberg loved it.
COMMENTARY: I just love it when controversy surrounds a venture capital firm, especially when it involves its founder, and that founder goes crazy spending investor capital. With so many key members of the managment team bailing out, some with just a few months on the job, it is clearly time to "abandon ship." Still no response from Mike Rothenberg. The SEC investigation must be going full speed ahead. There's probably a lot more going on besides the lavish spending. The shutdown of the website is another clear signal that this VC firm is not taking on any new startups. The high flying and party days are over for Rothenberg Ventures.
At the end of 2015, Rothenberg Ventures was the VC leader in the number of investments made in the AR/VR space with a total of 32 startups in which it had invested. These ventures are very early stage, so it remains to beseen whether any of them will pan out or ever reach unicorn status.
CB Insights Infographic of Leading VC firms investing the the AR-VR Space between 2011 and 2015 (Click Image To Enlarge)
It appears the Mike Rothenberg has a preference for founders who graduated from Stanford and Harvard. Mike attended both schools. An intriguing coincidence or preference on the part of Mike.
To be continued.